Innovation vs. Execution

Marty Cagan extends his earlier point that product teams must learn fast in discovery while still delivering with confidence, arguing that the balance depends heavily on company culture. He lists the traits of a strong innovation culture (experimentation, open minds, empowerment, technology and business savvy, skill diversity, discovery techniques) and contrasts them with those of a strong execution culture (urgency, high-integrity commitments, accountability, collaboration, results focus, recognition). He poses hard questions about whether the two cultures conflict and what kinds of people each requires. Cagan observes that few companies excel at both, and that the main barrier is willingness to change culture rather than knowing the techniques. He invites teams to honestly assess where they stand and where they need to be.

01Key takeaways

• Assess your team honestly on both innovation and execution, rather than assuming strength in one implies the other.
• Make it safe to run experiments where many fail, and reward learning, not just successful launches.
• Pair urgency with high-integrity commitments so that teams deliver on promises without burning out.
• Reward teams that tackle brutally hard commitments as well as those that come up with great new ideas.
• Recognize that culture change, not technique, is usually the hard part of improving innovation or execution.

02Key sections

Recap and purpose

Cagan picks up from his prior article on balancing fast discovery with confident delivery and frames the challenge as a question of culture. He sets out to describe what each culture looks like.

Traits of an innovation culture

Innovation is supported by tolerance for failed experiments, ideas from anywhere, empowered teams, use of new technology and data, deep business and customer understanding, and mechanisms for safe, quick testing.

Traits of an execution culture

Execution depends on a sense of urgency, high-integrity commitments, accountability with reputational consequences, collaboration, a results-oriented focus, and rewards that favor delivering on hard commitments.

Hard questions to consider

Cagan asks whether innovation and execution cultures inherently conflict, whether strong execution creates stressful environments, and which types of people thrive in each culture.

Where companies stand

Cagan notes that Amazon is a rare example of strength in both, that strong executors are often tough places to work, and that many companies are weak in one or both areas.

Call to self-assessment

He urges teams to assess themselves on both dimensions and decide where they want to be, noting that the hard part is willingly changing culture.

03From the post

“A partnership dedicated to teaching best practices to product teams and product leaders”

Summary and takeaways written by PM Atlas; quotes are short excerpts. © the original author.